After a strategic group analysis, list the channel access your business would need to reach its proposed position. The map is complete when the firms are plotted, but the investment decision still needs evidence that your business can reach customers there. Check that access before approving the move.
Strategic group analysis compares firms within an industry by the strategies they follow, showing groups with similar competitive positions.
A group map makes competitive positions visible
A completed map gives the strategy team a compact way to discuss its competitive choices. The axes show the characteristics selected for comparison. Firms cluster where they follow similar approaches. The map can help the team consider a different position without starting from an unstructured list of everything competitors do.
The BCcampus strategic management text describes strategic groups as firms following similar strategies. It also identifies mobility barriers that make changing groups difficult. An unoccupied position can therefore suggest an opportunity or reveal a difficult combination of requirements. The diagram alone does not distinguish between those explanations.
Use the map to describe the proposed move before using it to justify spending. Name the target customer and the way the business would serve that customer. Translate a plotted direction into an operating change. Moving toward broader distribution, for instance, requires something more specific than a larger mark on an axis.
| Access unconfirmed | Access supported | |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery ready | Confirm the customer route | Assess the commitment |
| Delivery uncertain | Resolve both barriers | Attractive position Still needs delivery evidence |
This schematic compares evidence for customer access with readiness to deliver. It is not an industry map or a rating of real firms. Its purpose is to distinguish a position that looks desirable from a move the business can execute. A firm can understand the desired offer while still lacking permission to sell through the required channel.
Retain the reasons for choosing the axes. If management plotted price and range, ask what those variables leave out of the proposed move. Customer access may depend on product availability, distribution agreements or a service capability absent from the picture. Add the relevant evidence to the investment paper rather than assuming the map has already considered it.
The broader discipline of strategic thinking begins with what the business seeks to achieve. Keep that purpose visible when comparing positions. A less crowded group is not automatically a useful destination. It must offer a result the business values and a feasible way to obtain it.
Ask the operating manager to describe the first customer transaction after the move. Trace how the customer finds the offer, how an order reaches the business and how delivery occurs. The purpose is to locate the channel requirement behind the plotted position. If the manager cannot identify who must agree to that transaction, the investment proposal still lacks a usable route to market.
Check the channel barrier your proposed position requires the business to cross. Start the Walk →
Can the business reach the proposed position?
Identify the most consequential barrier between the current and proposed positions. Ask who controls it and what evidence would establish access. The answer could concern a distributor agreement or the ability to provide the service customers expect. Avoid combining every capability gap into a single claim that the business is not ready.
The relevant frame is the route to customers, not the distance between plotted firms. A nearby position can require a distribution arrangement the business cannot obtain. A more distant position might use an existing customer relationship. Compare the actual route rather than interpreting geometric distance as effort or cost.
Write the barrier as a question that can affect the commitment. Can the required products be supplied on acceptable terms? Will the channel carry the proposed offer? Can the business meet the delivery obligations? Choose the question that could make the move infeasible. Investigating that question comes before approving the assets that depend on its answer.
Distinguish access from attractiveness. A customer segment may value the proposed offer, but that does not establish the business can reach it economically. Equally, an available channel may deliver customers who do not want that offer. The investment paper should show which conclusion the evidence supports and where it remains incomplete.
A barrier needs evidence from the party or process that can permit the move. Internal confidence cannot confirm another organization's supply commitment. A statement of interest cannot silently become an agreement. Ask the relevant owner what can be confirmed now, what remains conditional and what the conditions would cost.
This differs from closing a strategic gap in the current business. The immediate question is whether a proposed position can be reached on acceptable terms. A gap list can help organize the work, but it should not assume that management can purchase every missing capability.

Keep uncertainty about the route visible. An attractive target does not become less attractive because access is unresolved. It becomes a different decision: whether to obtain evidence about access before making a commitment that assumes it.
JD Sports and Footasylum faced close customer substitution
The CMA's November 2021 JD Sports and Footasylum decision illustrates why customer evidence matters. In its announcement requiring JD Sports to sell Footasylum, the regulator identified JD Sports as the closest alternative for Footasylum shoppers. It retained that conclusion after considering growth in online sales by manufacturers including Nike and adidas.
In the CMA's online survey, 50% of clothing shoppers and 43% of footwear shoppers said they would switch to JD Sports if they could not shop at Footasylum. These were conditional switching responses, not market shares. The findings supported the regulator's assessment of close competition between the two retailers.
The CMA inquiry record contains the remittal report and customer survey documents. This is merger evidence, not evidence that either retailer prepared a strategic group map. It does not prove that another firm could enter their position or obtain equivalent customer access.
An apparent channel alternative needs evidence that customers will treat it as an alternative. The illustrative connection to strategic group analysis is limited but useful. A map separating multi-brand retailers from direct manufacturer channels should not turn the existence of both channels into a conclusion that they serve customers interchangeably.
For a business proposing to move between such groups, the next task is to test the specific customer route. Identify what customers obtain through the target channel that the current business cannot yet provide. Then examine whether the proposed move can supply it. This is a prospective check for readers, not a description of either retailer's strategy process.
Use decision-relevant evidence to narrow the work. Survey questions about actual alternatives address a different issue from broad brand recognition. Supply discussions address a different issue again. Match the evidence to the barrier that the proposed investment depends on.
Test access before funding the move
Attach an access check to the repositioning proposal. State the proposed position and the barrier that could prevent reaching it. Record the evidence currently available and the condition needed before investment. Keep the authorizing decision distinct from work that gathers information about the route.
The investment should remain conditional while an essential route to customers is unresolved. Reduce the commitment where possible. Work that clarifies access may be justified before a broad operating change. A long lease or major equipment purchase requires stronger support when its value depends on a channel that has not agreed to participate.
The following pair represents an illustrative inconsistency within a single strategy proposal. It does not quote a real organization. The proposal cannot rely on both statements without resolving how the channel will supply the target customers.
Compare the proposed move with the option of retaining the current position. Strategic thinking precedes the implementation plan. A well-developed schedule cannot settle whether the route to the new position exists. Stop planning at the point where the next step depends on an unresolved barrier.
Record what evidence would make the move worth approving or abandoning. The Universal Decision-Making Method connects that judgment to purpose and sufficient certainty. Roger Estall and Grant Purdy describe it in Deciding. Applied here, it turns a mapped possibility into a choice about a supported commitment.
Assign someone to check the access condition before the next expenditure. If the condition changes, return to the decision before extending the commitment. Use monitoring of the chosen route to detect that change. Preserve the map as context, alongside the evidence explaining why the business can reach the position it has chosen.
What evidence shows your business can reach customers in the position on the map?
Work through your decisionNo sign-up. Just pick your decision and start.
Grant Purdy is the co-author, with Roger Estall, of Deciding (2020), and the architect of the Universal Decision-Making Method.